Screen to Print Match for Photographers

Most people have experienced an issue with screen to print match at one time or another. Some have told me that they have just given up on the idea. But screen to print match can save you a lot of editing time, and wasted paper making proofs (you know: proof-tweak, proof-tweak, etc.)

Actually, this is an issue that can usually be solved without breaking a sweat. Think of this article like a cooking recipe – put it all together, and cookies turn out fine!

Examples of Issues

1. It is hard to see the screen in my office or studio

2. Colors I’m familiar with don’t look right on the screen

3. Screen brightness does not match print/print looks too dark

4. Screen shows highlights and/or shadows differently than the print

5. Some colors differ on screen vs print

6. All the color in the print just looks wrong, compared to the screen

 

Discussion

1. It is hard to see the screen

This is a big cause of headaches and fatigue.

I suggest that if you need glasses or an updated prescription, get them. Bright light in the room, whether ceiling lights, windows, or other sources, can cause reflections on the screen or cause you struggle with differences in brightness. I use a room that has a big window with a set of louvered blinds. Not expensive, and effective.

If you are using a laptop, you should know that most laptop screens are just not good enough for editing color in digital photographs. The color palette is too narrow. Also, the screen has a small sweet spot, or angle of view – if you move around a bit the appearance of color and/or contrast may change. If your budget permits, get a decent flat screen display and plug it into the laptop.

 

2. Colors I’m familiar with don’t look right on the screen

First, you usually get what you pay for. A bottom-dollar low end screen probably can’t get the job done.

Next, the screen has to be calibrated – this means adjusting the screen so it shows color accurately as possible. The tool used for this is a display calibrator; the one I use is the iOne Display by X-Rite. (I discourage use of the display calibration software included with Mac OS or Windows OS. They improve things, but not enough for editing photographs).

Display calibration is one of the easier things to do. Open the box, follow the directions, and voila!

iOne Calibration

I have some recommendations for settings. Some may disagree here, but these work for me. You will see the adjustment screen for these if you choose the “advanced” option in your calibration software.

Use color temp of 5500k, or 6500k, depending partly on which color space you use. Adobe 98 white point is 6500, ProPhoto RGB is 5500.

Use luminance of 80-90 cd/square meter if you need to get as close as possible to paper white; some people find this is too dark, and go with 100-120c cd/sq mtr.

Use gamma of 2.0 or 2.2. Using 2.0 is a bit unorthodox, but I prefer it. Your mileage may vary.

When you set up your display like this, it will look kind of dull compared to its previous state.

By the way, most new displays come new out of the box set up to much higher color temperatures, close to 200cd/sqm, gamma native or 2.2. That’s useful in an office where one is working on email or similar stuff; near useless for photography.

You can, of course, experiment until you find a set of adjustments that suit you. These have worked for me for a long time.

One last thing: capture RAW whenever practical, and work with your images in Adobe 98, or ProPhoto RGB,  rather than sRGB.  The only reason to keep an sRGB workflow is if you are a wedding or event photographer and your lab requires it.

 

3. Screen brightness does not match print

The screen will always look brighter than the print. Put another way: “the print looks too dark!” Think of the screen like a lightbox with a big transparency on it – it gives off light. The print can only reflect light.

The answer comes in three parts: Control your room lighting, use the screen brightness settings provided above, and control the light used to view the print (view the print in indirect daylight, gallery halogens, or a dedicated light box).

 

4. Screen shows highlights and/or shadows differently than the print

Two of the biggest reasons in the matching screen-vs-print category for this are 1) a cheapo screen, and 2) a non-calibrated display.

Other causes usually involve editing techniques used in Photoshop or another editor, when preparing to print, or in settings used in the printing software dialogue box. That’s a subject for another article.

 

5. Some colors differ on screen vs print

First, think about display calibration. Got to do it – at least once a month.

Next, think about setting up Photoshop so you can actually see what the printed image’s colors will look like. This kind of preview is called “Soft Proofing”. Here’s an excerpt from an article I wrote on the subject:

You can set Photoshop to display a simulation of how your your print will actually look, using the paper/ink/printer combination you’ve chosen. This is often called 
“soft proofing”.

The benefits? You can see, in real time, what color impact your editing will produce – in other words, each time you adjust color you’ll see what it is going to look like in the final print. You can also choose different soft proofing setups to see the impact of changing papers, or even changing printers!

With your image open, click View>Proof Setup>Custom, as shown below:

Step OneThe next dialogue box that appears will look like this:

sp2

Note that just below the tag “Proof Conditions” there is a title “Device to Simulate”. This designates a drop down menu that looks like the screen shot shown below. You will see a list of the ICC profiles that you’ve installed, either along with a printer driver, or manually. Scroll down and choose the one you want.

sp3

 

Once you have chosen the correct profile, you can save this as a pre-set for your convenience. Click on Save, and name your pre-set, and click save again. Click OK to close this out.

sp4

 

For most photography purposes, Perceptual rendering intent is fine. Enable black point compensation, and leave the others alone – don’t need them. As long as “Preview” is enabled, your calibrated display will show you what your image is going to look like in print!

 

6. All the color in the print just looks wrong, compared to the screen

The biggest reason this happens to me is that, somehow, the display calibration goes haywire. This usually happens after a system crash.

The first thing to do is to check the printer – is the right paper loaded? Are you using the right printer settings? Have you performed a print head check for clogged nozzles?

If the problem continues, reboot the computer and recalibrate the display. Sometimes settings files go haywire, or get corrupted. If the display is over three or four years old, and the problem persists, try another monitor on the computer and see if that solves the issue. You may need a new display.

 

Additional tips and tricks:

Remember that you can always change your display calibration back to the way it was, or re-calibrate using different settings.

Color editing that seems impossible late at night will usually be easy after a good night’s sleep.

Use manufacturer’s ink, not a substitute, in your printer.

Experiment with different papers, but often the manufacturer’s paper will look the best.

If you have trouble with color on a print, try making a print from an image that has done well before. If that also looks different, it is the printer or the printing settings.

Change the background on your Photoshop screen to grey or white.

Let the screen warm up for 30 minutes before you start work.

When you are printing, try using ICC profiles for printing instead of printer managed color.

===


 

LOTS MORE INFO AND REGISTER HERE FOR FREE WEBINAR “End-to-End Workflow for Creative Photographers”

NEWS FLASH! Special Nik software coupon code “dsaffir” just for my blog readers.
Nik  also  has  “Black  Friday”  reduction for  7  days – so  Silver  Efex  Pro  is only 139 with the code.
Go to niksoftware.com.

12 thoughts on “Screen to Print Match for Photographers

  1. Pingback: David Saffir :: Screen to Print Match for Photographers at Imaging Insider

  2. Pingback: Tutorial/Tips Watch (May 26, 2009) at Imaging Insider

  3. Pingback: Screen to Print Match « The Palouse Guy

  4. Pingback: Photo News Today » Blog Archive » Photo News Today

  5. There are some things though… There is a lot of flat out lying going on the sales of monitors… A REAL 8 bit monitor is going to cost some money and the stats on the box are usually false about how many colors a monitor will produce.

    Make your screen background 127,127, 127 gray. Get rid of all the fancy colored pictures and hundreds of mind boggling files and folders on the desktop. All that stuff does is ruin your eyeball for perception of color. If you;re male and over 45 you’re already half blind as it is… why make it tougher?

    Organize your computer. I just can’t believe all the people I work with who can’t find a file at the snap of a finger or even 20 minutes later… When you save something where is it going? What name did you give it so you can find it later?

    Control the lights. I have brought my SPYDER Pro3 to several clients’ offices to calibrate their monitors for them and the puck just gives up and says the ambient light is too high. I have 2 clients who work in a blast furnace of flourescent light. There is simply no way to calibrate a monitor in that environment.

    Obtain perfect files from labs so you can test them on the monitor and get them printed.

    Go here for specific detailed mind numbing instructions on monitors and color control: http://www.gballard.net/psd.html

    Go here for how to fix Firefox color management:

    http://photomaking.wordpress.com/browsers-and-photography/

    Safari needs no fix and runs on both PC and MAC. Internet Explorer is probably hopeless as a color managed browser since Microsoft will not conform to ICC stuff.

  6. Ambient light can be a significant problem. I find that many who wear glasses have even more trouble, and overhead office lights make things nearly impossible. They’re dealing with strong light competing with the screen, and reflections from the office lighting.

    Monitor quality is also a challenging issue. There are a number of reviews of individual models, but not a whole lot of info providing side-by-side comparisons, or even fact checking on manufacturer’s claims. If one is careful in selecting a model, brands like Lacie, Eizo, HP, NEC, and a few others can be good. Every time I get a new monitor, I go out and do the research – gotta live with the thing for hours each day.

  7. Pingback: Using Photoshop’s “Replace Color” Tool to Enhance Landscape and Scenic Images « David Saffir's Photography and Printing Blog

  8. Excellent post!! Thanks so much David. Screen to print match is an ever-challenging subject for me. But it’s getting a bit easier. I like your ‘light-box’ analogy, it’s so true. I’m using this one local uber print house and the color of the prints are coming out very close to what is being displayed on my monitor, I’m very happy.

    The prints are still a tad dark. Now do you suggest that I bump down my brightness/contrast on my monitor? Or leave it and make my final save my final file a bit ‘brighter’? I would love to hear what you suggest. Thanks so much.

    • I would re-calibrate to a lower luminance level. Reducing screen brightness using on-monitor controls
      may affect accuracy of your monitor profile.

      I target luminance between 90-110 cd/m2

      David

  9. Pingback: The Ultimate Adjustment Layer in Photoshop – Using Smart Objects « David Saffir's Photography and Printing Blog

  10. Pingback: Top Photo and Printing Posts of 2010 – and 100,000 visitors! « David Saffir's Photography and Printing Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s